Skip's 4x4
Kia
Sorento: Review & Service History
|
Reviews and
Service History page
Ok, so I took delivery of my Kia
Sorento in November 2008. It drove real nice. Fast, economical, handled
well, prety sporty and quiet for a diesel. But, right from Day 1, I
noticed that the vehicle had some characteristics that were not quite
right.
Problems listed post-delivery in the 1000k service only a week or 2 after purchase.
The most immediate and obvious fault was the immobiliser. This
was reported to Wangara Kia, and they investigated the problem, but it was not
resolved. For a detailed description of fault, see the PDF document in
the following paragraphs.
Problems listed for 1st service at 15000k on 24 Apr 2009.
- Immobiliser fault
- Lack of grease on front tailshaft
- Engine management system program diagnose / update.
- Auto Transmission management system diagnose / update.
- Cruise control is erratic.
- Windscreen washer left nozzle low pressure.
Read my full detailed report of these issues. Click here for report in PDF format.
RESULT: Kia replaced a
"component" of the imobiliser system, but the problem was not fixed
(the unit that was ordered and subsequently replaced about a week later
was called a "smartra" unit). They did grease the front tailshaft but
it still seemed to have some play, although did not cause any problems
in driving with 4wd engaged. They said that they checked for an
"update" to the ECU unit, that controls all 3 of the major electronic
systems (Engine, Auto trans, and cruise conrtol), but I did not notice
any significant improvement. They said that the ECU did not report any
error codes, but there had been a TSB (Technical Services Bulletin)
released by Kia for the cruise control for this model, and that I would
be informed of updates. Service cost $305
Problems listed for 2nd service at 30000k on 17 Sep 2009.
New problems since last service:
- Noisy windscreen Wipers.
- Annoying “knocking” sound coming from inside rear tailgate
- Possible problem with right front low-beam headlight
Warranty issues still requiring attention from previous service:
- Immobiliser fault
- Lack of grease in front tailshaft
- Engine management system program diagnose / update
- Auto Transmission management system diagnose / update
- Cruise control is erratic
- Windscreen washer left nozzle low pressure
Read my full detailed report of these issues. Click here for report in PDF format.
RESULT: Kia replaced
another
"component" of the imobiliser system (this time, the antenna, again, on
a subsequent visit about a week later), but the problem was not fixed.
They did grease the front tailshaft (again) but it still seemed to have
some
play (according to a private independant mechanic), although still did
not cause any problems in driving with 4wd engaged.
They said that they applied an "update" to the ECU unit, that controls
all 3 of the major electronic systems (Engine, Auto trans, and cruise
conrtol), but I did not notice any significant improvement. The
knocking in the rear tail gate was apparantly the stiker plate had gone
out of allignment, which was fixed by re-aligning it. They claim that
the right-front headlight globe was installed "upside down", which is
really odd, given that it was fine before, and I cant see any reason
why any other person who has worked on my car (auto electrician etc)
would have removed or replaced it. Service cost $687
Car towed to Kia, with a dead starter motor ~Oct 2009.
Starter motor died a
week or 2 after going off-road in some dusty and rainy conditions. At
first it started "grinding" when trying to start it, getting worse over
a week or so, till eventually it would not mesh at all... it would spin
up, but not crank the engine. Kia tried to get out of warranty as I had
been "of road", and I argued that I should not have to buy a new
starter motor
for $730, as the car is meant to be able to go off road. Finally, they
gave in and replaced starter motor under warranty.
Problems listed for 3rd service at 45000k on 8 Apr 2010.
New problems since last service:
Warranty issues still requiring attention from previous service:
- Immobiliser fault
- Engine management system program diagnose / update
- Auto Transmission management system diagnose / update
- Cruise control is erratic
- Windscreen washer left nozzle low pressure
RESULT: Given up on
the smaller problems like noisy windscreen wipers, and low pressure on
left washer jet... these must just be characteristics (design faults)
of this vehicle. Again, the engine ECU reported no faults, and Kia also
said that there were no updates to ECU available. All the normal
problems remained... intermittant immobiliser, flat spot in engine,
sometimes erratic gear changes etc. The did do a front wheel allignment
on the car, as mine (and others apparantly) do sometimes pull (steer)
to the left. Mine did this from day 1, but was corrected by WA
Suspensions when they fitted king springs to the car... apparantly the
wheel allignment was out from the factory. Perhaps they have a tendancy
to go out of allignment, as it require re-alligning within a year. I
find the pull to the left to be minimul, easy to get used to, and not a
problem. As for the oil leak, they washed the engine bay down with a
pressure cleaner, then said "no leak found". Hmmm. Service cost $776
.... and shortly afterwards...
The leak obviously
resumed the next day, and the vehicle ended up going back a further 2
times, 1 to see the fresh oil and identify that it was the front
crankshaft seal that was leaking, and then again once the new seal had
arrived, and was fitted under warranty (not before Kia tried to get out
of the warranty by saying that it was my fault for "taking the vehicle
off road")
Car towed to Kia, with a dead starter motor (again) 13 July 2010.
Not much to say about
this. Went off road (slushy conditions), starter motor died a week or 2
later. Kia tried to get out of warranty as I had been "of road", again,
and again I argued that I should not have to buy a new starter motor
for $730, as the car is meant to be able to go off road. Finally, they
gave in and replaced starter motor under warranty. Mysteriously, on of
my headlight globes blew on the same day, and so I bought a new globe
from Kia for $18. ALso, if memory serves me well, and ECU update had
become available, and was applied whilst Kia had the car. Not much
improvement to 2 of the 3 ECU related problems, but the 3rd, the cruise
control, was definitly improved, and is now quite usable (although not
perfect)
Problems listed for 4th service at 60000k on 21 Sep 2010.
New problems since last service:
- Oil leak under engine (a different, new oil leak)
Warranty issues still requiring attention from previous service:
- Immobiliser fault
- Engine management system program diagnose / update
- Auto Transmission management system diagnose / update
RESULT: Immobiliser
transponder error is present (finally!). Requires a new smartra unit
(again!). This was not in stock, so vehicle went back a week later to
have it replaced, and whallah! Problem fixed. For the firt time since
new, the car starts first time, every time. Engine oil leak was
reported as "coming from the intercooler". Very odd since the
intercooler is air-to-air... that is that none of its components and
pipes have oil circulating in them! The intercooler was noted as being
a little bent, due to an "impact", but I have checked it and it remains
air tight, and so has no effect on the vehicle whatsoever. And for the
record, the "Impact" is almost unavoidable when off-roading, as it (the intercooler) is
mounted far too low under the front of the vehicle... if the car has to
go up a steep incline, or slightly "bounces" over small lump, then the
intercooler is the first item to hit the ground. And the flimsy bash
plate provided is of no help at all. Kia have therefore refused to
locate and fix this oil leak, and in fact have asked me to spend $630
on a new intercooler, which I can't afford, nor justify (especially
since they wont guarantee that they will fix the oil leak even if I do
buy the new intercooler). Re engine flatspots and sometimes erratic
gear changes, there were no error codes reported, and further ECU
upgrades available. I am begining to think that these problems in Kia's
programming of the ECU are not going to be fixed, especially since the
all new Sorento has been launched (and the new Sorento is certainly not
aimed at off roading, with it's lack of chassis, no live rear axle, and
no low range). Also in this service, I was told that I needed new front
rotors. When asking if they can just be machined, I was told that
machining them would take them below minimum size, and so they wont do
it. So, let me get this right... Kia have designed a vehicle that has
front rotors that are so thin, that they cant be machined even once? As
time goes on, I am beginning to see why the Kia was less expensive than
other vehicles in it's class. Anyway, I said NO to the new rotors, and
took my car to a brake specialist, who said that my rotors were fine,
and did not even need machining, so on with a new set of pads, and the
brakes were fine.
Problems listed for 5th service at 75000k on 18 Apr 2011.
New problems since last service:
- Vibration / rumble in
driveline somewhere that occurs only over 100kph. Possibly a universal joint,
or wheel bearing.
- Trim falling off. Carpet
trim under rear of front passenger seat is falling off. ALSO 2 x trim covering
the bolts at the front of the Rear seats keeps falling off.
Warranty issues still requiring attention from previous service:
- Engine still has flat spot. See details description (follows).
- Oil leak from engine.
- Windscreen washer... several nozzles blocked.
- Rattle behind the dash, coming from top left corner.
Read my full detailed report of these issues. Click here for report in PDF format.
RESULT:
Kia said that they could not test drive the car at 100kph due to local
speed limits, and therefore claimed that no fault found. A very
unprofessional respons, as the car definitly has a fault, and it's
getting worse. I am convinced that it's a wheel bearing, and that any
decent mechanic could locate it, even if it meant a quick run down the
freeway at 100kph! They ignored the oil leak. They unblocked the
windscreen nozzles (again). They said that they could not reproduce the
(anoying) dashboard rattle... they ovbiously did not try hard, as it
happens when going oven even small ripples in the road (yes, at 60kph
or less!). The engine management system did not have any error codes,
so again they ignored the flat spot issue, and they completely
disregarded the trim falling off, and tried to tell me that this was
not a warranty issue.
Imobiliser goes faulty again, getting worse towards end of April.
All
of a sudden, my car's imobiliser starts to play up again, oftern taking
several minutes of attempts before the imobiliser is de-activated,
allowing the car to start. I cant believe this most annoying problem is
back! This time I filmed it, on this particular occasion, I attempted
to start it repeatedly for more than 3 minutes, and it would not
display the little "key" light on the dash, indicating that it was
de-imobilised and ready to start. I ended up giving up, stopped
filming, went and got the number for the tow truck, then gave it 1 last
try and it started. It seams very random, sometimes, playing up every
single time you try to start it, for days on end, and then will be fine
for several days. It's most odd. Click here to view my video of it's starting problem.
Intercooler taken for 2nd opinion on 9 May 2011.
I
took my car to Odin Radiators to get a 2nd opinion on the intercooler,
as Kia have mentioned again about the bent Intercooler in the last
service, and wanted to charge me $650 + gst + labour (not much change
from $1000). They checked it and said that it is definitly not leaking,
and will not effect performance of the vehicle at all. THey also agreed
that it was nothing to do with the oil leak. They said that although
they could not easily repaire (straighten out) the intercooler, they
could supply a new genuine Kia intercooler for more then $100 less. I
chose to not proceed as it is working correctly.
Car taken back to Kia for warranty work on 11 May 2011.
Read my full detailed report of the requested warranty issues. Click here for report in PDF format.
Totally
frustrated by Kia's lack of action on the warranty issues reported at
last service, I booked the car back to Wangara Kia specifically to have
the warranty issues sorted. I also reported a new problem... the car's
CD player now refused to play most CD's, reporting an "Error 5". They
Kept the car until end of 17 May, so I was carless for 7 days, 4 of
which were working days. After this period, they asked me to come and
collect my car, as they were still waiting for permission to proceed on
the warranty work... that's right, they did NOTHING over this period. I
am starting to get the impression that they really just dont care, and
perhaps they are just putting me out with the hope that I may give up.
Complaint lodged with Kia Australia on 18 May 2011.
Ok,
enough is enough. I phones Kia and lodged an official complaint. They
said all the right things and said they would get onto Wangara Kia to
try to get things moving along. A week later, they called back, saying
that they had not forgot. A week after that, still no contact.
Given up... 4 June 2011.
Ok,
so I gave up. Owning a car is meant to be a pleasurable experience.
It's meant to provide reliable transport, stress free, without the
hassles. My Kia Sorento has done nothing but cause me grief, and Kia
have showed little interest to repair defects in my car, some of which
have been there since day 1. So on Saturday the 4th June, I decided to
retire it. I got the All Terrain tyres removed and put back on the
original street tryes. I removed my Phone's in-car kit, removed the
wiring to the rear power socket, removed my TomTom GPS, my spotties,
antenna, returning the car to it's original state, and advertised it
for sale on a local website.
Update... 2 Nov 2011.
Well, I had been trying to sell the car on and off via Gumtree for the
last few months, but no takers. It seems that either $25k asking
price is too high, or they get put off by the noisy wheel bearing
(which is quite loud now), or the oil soaked underside of the engine
bay. So, it looks like I have to push on and try to get Kia to fix it.
So, I bit the bullet and last week on 26 Oct 2011, I got my mechanic to
fit a new Genuine Kia Intercooler to the car, at a cost of $750. He
confirmed 3 things. 1) the oil seems to be coming from the front main
crank seal (how odd that the Kia mechanics could not pin point this).
2) The Noise is the right front wheel bearing (again, frustrating that
Kia Mechanics just pretended they could not hear it and said no fault
found. 3) there was oil inside the intercooler, and the only place
upstream of the intercooler that this could be coming from is a faulty
oil seal in the turbo, so it looks like another fault brewing. I still
have not had any follow up from the official Kia complaints department,
and so I have booking it in (again) to Wangara Kia on 7th Nov 2011,
asking them to fix the wheel bearing and engine oil leaks (again)...
let's hope they actually do something this time. Fingers crossed.
Update... 7 Nov 2011.
Ok, so it went to Wangara Kia today. I had a huge argument with them as
they wanted to charge me to look at each issue. I took a punt and let
them proceed. Luckily, they agreed that both the wheel bearing and oil
leak were warranty items. They proceeded and replaced the right front
wheel bearing, and wow, it drives beautiful now, very quite and smooth,
just like it used to when new! Nice. The oil seal has been ordered,
being the front main crank seal. They also said that there was oil
inside the intercooler pipes, and explained that there was too much oil
in the engine. This I dispute, as my regular mechanic is a senior, well
experienced mechanic, and I was actually there when he changed the oil,
and witnessed him start the engine, let it settle, then check the oil
level several times. Kia went on to say that this is a common problem
on the Kia Sorento, and their solution is to put a little less oil in
the engine, saying around 3/4 on the dip-stick is good. They claim that
any higher and the excess oil will be expelled through the turbo,
ending up in the intercooler. Hmmm. So they said the turbo is fine.
Update... 8 Nov 2011.
I have had the car advertised on a free web site for a while, and today
I had someone drive the car, and with it driving so well now, they
loved it and decide to purchase it, at the full asking price of $25k. I
have accepted a deposit and they
will pick up in 1 week. Not sure if the oild seal will arrive before
it's collected, but I guess if not the new owner can get Kia to fix it
anyway.
Update... 18 Nov 2011.
The car sale was complete, and the new owner drove it away. I had not yet heard from Kia re the oil seal.
Update... 25 Nov 2011.
Wangara Kia called to say the oil seal had arrived, and I explained that I had sold the car.
Back to my Kia's
Specs Page or
to my Fitout Page
Email
Alan (me) for
more info. Email me
The best computer
company: Heppell I.T.,
This page was last updated on 18 Nov 2011